Like many have already said, I am a person whose work requires rigid separation due to the nature of my work. Keeping work and personal separated will allow me to limit the amount of notes that I will end up losing in the inevitable situation that I no longer work at the company.
besides a pure necessity to separate, I could also see fiction writing benefiting from a separate vault, to keep notes about that specific fictional world separate from the author’s nonfiction notes.
Am I right in thinking that there’s no real lock-in or punishment to choosing one option or another?
That is, is moving from one to multiple vaults simly a matter of dragging the relevant folders/files into the other vault?
I just really wish Obsidian worked off a single environment for plugins, settings etc … because I like the config I have and I don’t want the extra labour of managing distinct environments.
I’m contemplating going from one to multiple. I’m not an extensive user but, having finally settled on a particular project to make notes on (language learning), I find that the majority of use is within that folder whilst everything else is still kind of nascent/half-use. I’m thinking about bringing a bit of focus to things - well, focus around that one purposeful area and then we’ll see about the rest…
Maybe the alternative is I adopt a PARA approach. With area folders:
a) it feels hard to access the active information within, in a distinct project folder
b) there is a distraction from what are different area categories.
I think the P of PARA is for active projects, which are later moved to areas.
Moving my language learning folder to a Projects folder, rather than buried down a few layers in what is otherwise exactly the right themetic area, might bring some immediacy to it, negating the need for a vault split. Just a thought.
We are moving in similar directions! I’m planning to start a couple more vaults for specialized purposes (the main one will still cover many different things) and am migrating to a PARA-ish setup. So far I like it pretty well; we’ll see how it holds up over time.
The only punishment to multiple vaults that I know of is the environment stuff you mention and the diminished linking between them.
A new reason is Canvas, if your use of any single canvas covers multiple vaults (eg dashboards).
Nested vaults work well and give a degree of linking as well as separation.
Otherwise, if linking between these vaults is important, then they ought to be folders only.
The environment stuff is certainly a cost to multiple vaults since all updates etc need to be done per vault. I use few, rarely updated plugins, and even fewer themes (usually default unless it glares too much), so my cost is relatively low but I still go through the update routine every time I open a vault.
Nested vaults don’t work on mobile, as far as I know.
Long time since I used mobile, but they worked then (Android).
Still seems to work.
Might be an iOS issue.
Reasonable presumption.
Of course, there may be issues on Android that I’d encounter if I actively used mobile. Which I might when Canvas comes.
There’s a general situation on mobile with limited resources compared to desktop, for some at least. And the quality and design of sync arrangements. I have the mobile resources but I still don’t have my large over-everything vault on mobile because I never needed it there.
I find it difficult to keep everything in the same Vault.
But I would love to do that! This is what stops me:
What I do now:
In the ideal world, I would like to have one Vault for everything, but easily “turn off” and “turn on” folders to make the contents less visible in search and in the interface. This setting should be different for different machines.
I want to give an update to how I manage having several vaults now. As you can see, it is actually a combination of one vault and multiple vaults, or one vault that is compartmentalized. As I wrote earlier in this thread, I use a big chunk of my notes at work. I only synchronize those notes with my work computer. For this, multiple vaults helps.
I’ve organized my notes into this folder structure:
I have four devices that I synchronize between: My personal laptop, my personal stationary and my personal phone. These I synchronize all my folders via Syncthing. My fourth device, work computer, I only synchronize the folder 2B. Work. At my work office, I open 2B. Work as my vault. (Strictly speaking, I have a top folder where my obsidian configuration files are, and inside that folder is 2B. Work).
Single vault is still my default option. When I’m not at work, I simply open the top folder on any of my personal devices, that includes both 1 Private and 2 Pick my brain. In this way, I practically still have one, single vault. When I’m on any of my personal devices, I can search and link to anything else I’ve ever written in Obsidian.
Pick my brain. The reason I have separated 1 Private from 2 Pick my brain, is that I want to be able to show other people my vault without having to fear stumbling into the parts of my second brain that are too exposing or sensitive. If I want to surf my second brain with someone, I open 2 Pick my brain as a vault and feel confident that we can go wherever we might want to.
Sorting the notes. All new notes created on my three personal devices go into 0 Incoming. At the end of the day, or the following days when I have time, I move all the new notes into their respective places. So, if I had a session of writing notes on things that are related in the least way to work, I put that in 2B. Work and it will synchronize to all four devices. If I wrote something that I deem the least private, and don’t want others to browse around in, I put that in 1 Private. Everything else, that I don’t want synchronized to my work computer, goes into 2A General.
Using Syncthing. After having tried several synchronization services, I’m finally happy to use Syncthing and it has been working with almost zero error for half a year and daily synchronizing over 12.000 notes. Nextcloud could not handle that amount of notes and technical workers had to give up. The distributed synching between four devices mean I have a lot of redundancy.
I’m using separate vault for Evernote imports so that I can go through and eliminate what I don’t want so as not to clutter up my main vault.
@quinncom please could you share your Shortcuts shortcut/info? This ability to sync settings across both macOS and iOS is exactly what I need.
I personally prefer to use a single vault. I’ve argued in this direction in my Obsidian Starter Course for the following reasons:
At the end of the day, it remains an opinion. My situation is not yours, and you might actually need the separation of concerns for different reasons (e.g., work restrictions, GDPR, etc). The cool thing is that if you put aside plugins/templates/themes, etc, it remains easy to merge or split your vault(s) if needed.
In iOS, do you use WorkingCopy to sync every one of the vaults? Or do you just do it on the Main vault?
@mlte 
this might be the perfect solution for me, thanks for sharing! …curious to know if it’s still working for you?
I’m currently (happily) paying for the Obsidian Sync service. If Obsidian had password protection on Settings > Sync > Manage excluded folders, your workflow would be fully supported by the Sync service, or am I missing something?
This pain point is the only thing that I miss about OneNote, which made it very easy to separate work and personal notes, and move those notes (along with images or other embedded files) between Notebooks (equivalent to Vaults).
Hi there @senorvalenz . Yes, I’m still happy with this setup. I’ve made minor improvements to accommodate the difference between sharing my vault with close friends and everyone else. But otherwise it’s the same as above. I can access the notes I need everyday from multiple devices in their right context. Counting 15.000 notes and I practically never have any conflicted copies. I couldn’t be more satisfied.
I wouldn’t mind supporting the development of Obsidian anyway, but I am really happy with Syncthing.
I guess if there are no sensible or useful links between two or more different areas of interest there’s no value putting them in one vault and it may even confuse things. For example I’m learning French and have a separate vault for that. The words, definitions, verb tables in there are essentially “random words” that do not need linking to the rest of my stuff and would only cause confusion!
I use one universal vault. I have “archived” vaults that will get refactored into my new vault.
In your example I just might do the same, but I think there are very few exceptions. The problem with that logic is you assume you can judge the existence of a valuable overlap between field beforehand. Experience tells everyone that if you continue to explore and engage yourself in two separate fields, you will start to notice links between them. As long as those fields are in separate vaults those links can’t happen in the way Obsidian makes it possible. The power of one vault is you can get maximally surprised by your own thinking.