I also believe Option 1 is the way to go. +1 for that
This is not possible, at least at the moment. The new Browser file API is bare bone and lacks many features the provided by Electron (Nodeās FS API). Obsidian functionality canāt be implemented on top of it.
2 Likes
What about using Obsidian Sync instead? It is extremely expensive, but could be a solution, maybe? Or do you think it might also be possible to use git for syncing in a browser-version of Obsidian? There are a number of projects which allow sync to git within the browser, if Iām not mistaken. Of course, I donāt know if that would work for electron/Obsidian.
+1 to this idea. Iād pay significantly more for Obsidian Sync (as an add on to the Sync subscription perhaps? This would also make the sync subscription much more attractive to me vs just using iCloud) if it came with the ability to run Obsidian in the browser/web directly hooked up to the vault on Obsidian Sync servers.
- This solves the corporate install issue
- More ways to access is always better (ex: if I am on my wifeās iPad, much less friction to go to the web app vs set up the app just so I can save a web note or something). All the data is already on Obsidians server if I am using Sync!
- Folks who are principally opposed to having the app on the web due to privacy concerns need not worry; if the data backend is coming from Obsidian Sync, they wouldnāt be impacted at all since they would also have been opposed to using the Sync feature anyway
- Could E2E be preserved if there was some sort of device onboarding process where an authenticated device provided a key to the device wanting to access via web? That would be still a bit of friction but solve some of the use cases mentioned upthread.
2 Likes
Signed up just to say I would love a web app. I spent the last 6 months getting really used to keeping my notes in Obsidian and now that is essentially gone as I cannot install onto my new corporate laptop at my new job.
2 Likes
I signed up as well just to say that. It would be great to have a web solution, where the vault is placed at onedrive, google drive etc. So you can work on your vault from work. My work is very restricted regardingen installing software, so Obsidian is not an option, which is sad, because in worklift Obsidan can make a huge difference. So please look in to it - thanks.
2 Likes
Another +1. I can install on work devices, but I donāt want to mix personal and work. I run personal apps in a browser for this reason.
On the subject of E2E encryption, surely it wouldnāt be necessary to download the whole database from sync? the client running in the browser would just need the keys to decrypt the data. See how e.g. Proton Mail works.
The crucial difference is that ProtonMail works on one email at a time, Obsidian manages your whole vault at once. To make linked/unlinked mention work (and be up to date).
Protonmail also has plaintext access to the emailās metadata (recipients, subject), that facilitates some of their operations. Obsidian Sync does not have access to fileās metadata (filename, attributes)
1 Like
i presume desktop obsidian makes ad hoc calls to perform those tasks, it doesnāt keep the whole vault in memory?
a solution would be to decrypt and download a metadata cache/index of some sort. but itās a complex problem to be sure, and lots of effort to overcome.
Also signed up to say I would love a (even a simplified) web version. Main reason - to be able to access from work.
This is really the only downside of Obsidian for me at the moment.
1 Like
I donāt think it will happen anytime soon.
1 Like
@ariehen Can you add some reasons or even quotes? Thatās a statement that needs some more than just that 
Your thoughts are yours.
Obsidian stores notes on your device, so you can access them quickly, even offline. No one else can read them, not even us.
and:
3 Likes
Iām new to Obsidian and very impressed - but quite disappointed that it doesnāt have a web interface. Not sure what to do.
Itās kindāof ironic that the app and plugins are built with web technologies, the content is web friendly, and yet it the web is the only platform it doesnāt support.
My preference would be for a full normal cloud based implementation. This means the E2E encryption would become optional. Users who want cloud based access would have to turn it off.
I care very much about security but I think E2E is overrated. In choosing to use Obsidian I am putting my trust and faith in Obsidian inc. whether they implement E2E or not. There are, of course, still some advantages to E2E (in case they get hacked) so E2E makes sense as long as they are not providing any server side functionality, but I would not have a problem opting to turn it off in exchange for new functionality.
1 Like
Iām not very knowledgeable about web apps but isnāt obsidian made similarly to a website and wouldnāt that make it somewhat easy to make it a web application?
1 Like
Not saying you are wrong, but somehow Notesnook and Standard Notes manage to have a fully E2EE vault that supports text, images, lists and all the other things while still offering web clients.
Likewise. I was thinking since Obsidian was based on VS Code it can also build something like hosted UI version like Github Codespaces and Google IDX, and provides it as hosted version with pay membership, or self-hosted with licensing fees etc.
But it isnāt
Oops I made an uneducated guess. Thanks for clarifying @Dor. Is there anywhere to see source code? Being an early user I am surprised that Obsidian didnāt built upon VS Code since the app feels very similar to vs-code and runs so well from day one!
Please, pleaseš make the web app happen.
I work in a corporate setting where installed software is stringently controlled. It would take a great deal if not impossible to get obsidian installed, especially with an app that has community plugins.
I would like to take full potential of using my notes at work with the graph view and links.
Having a web app would solve that problem. It is my work where my notes are most useful, not at home.
I can use mobile app for now, but it significantly affects my workflow, particularly if I wanna add information to my notes from my work PC.
1 Like