Can't move file to folder that contains a file with the same name but different capitalization

Steps to reproduce

I’m trying to move a file from a folder to another that contains a file with the same name, the only difference is they have different capitalizations (one is Zenith.md and the other one ZENITH.md).

When I try to move the file nothing happens.

If they had exactly the same capitalization Obsidian would add .1 to the second file which is the expected behavior but I believe it should be case insensitive in this case, as the system sees them as the same file, so should Obsidian.

Environment

Obsidian version: v1.6.7
Installer version: v1.6.7
Operating system: Windows 11 Pro 10.0.22621
1 Like

I just checked on MacOS where I thought it was allowed to have both files together, but MacOS blocks it too. I had wondered if it was just a Windows thing, but no.

So +1

Maybe they’ll end up moving this to Feature Requests, but I agree it should either act consistently, or at least give a warning or feedback that the operation failed.

Moving by dragging, or via the command results in the same silent failure.

1 Like

At the very least, Obsidian should pop open the standard macOS response to attempting to move a file into a folder if another file with the same name exists in that folder:

“Keep Both” results in appending a digit to the end of the file name.

1 Like

thanks, we should add NAME 1 to name int hat case.

1 Like

Obsidian will have to add the “1” because its links are case-insensitive.

will be fixed 1.7.2