#14

Depends on the kind of information in a directory.

For nearly every directory I describe what kind of material belongs here. Once your storage exceeds a few tens of documents, a hierarchical structure with nouns or short phrases will not describe succinctly enough what the stuff is about.

I keep a store of reference material from different sources. One directory might stand for a topic and the notes for the directory outline the provenience and the quality of the material contained therein, as well as stuff still to be provided, work to be done. Individual document might need further documentation, including but not limited to meta data and work to be done.

Directories standing for projects and other units of work profit greatly from notes outlining the goals, work to be done, expected events and whatever I need to remember for a variable amount of time.

#15

Because taking notes (for me) results in:

  • A deeper understanding of documentation and tutorials
  • A quick reference of materials I can review once the skill fades
  • A remixing of all of those sources into my own understanding
  • A breadcrumb trail of my progression as I learn
  • A polishing of those remixes and breadcrumbs becomes content I post, or further pipeline workflows I develop for my work.

Obsidian doesn’t uniquely solve those problems, of course. I’ve been taking notes for decades. But it has one of the most enjoyable workflows for me. Ultimately, I see software like musical genres; all the rationalization barely matters. If it suits you it suits you, and if it doesn’t, it doesn’t. I enjoy the aesthetics of Obsidian.

2 Likes
#16
  1. How is a deeper understanding of documentation and tutorials beneficial for a specific task?
  2. DO you actually review those materials?
  3. How does remixing benefit you?
  4. How does the breadcrumb benefit you in the future?

We seem to have different goals here. You seem to organize for the sake of an assumed future need.

#17

What exactly are you trying to solve here? What is your goal? Why would you store any information without an assumed future need?

1 Like
#18

Eh? Whenever you organize, you do so for an assumed future need.
Why prepare for something you don’t think it might be needed?
You can not possible prepare for something that’s not in the future.
While it’s in the future, you only can presume that there will be a need. You will know whether you needed it or not when the time has passed.

How serious are those questions, indeed? Trying to goad someone?

2 Likes
#19

It is better to test your system than to continue building to then realize that all work might have been in vain.
That is - btw - exactly what happens to most startups who develop tangentially to market need. What determining market need is to startups is what testing the system for usability for every obsidian user.
I noticed a “I am sure it’ll be of use some time in the future” mentality here often and I don’t like that mentality.
I would rather talk to people who judge their workflow and data collection honestly and are willing to throw it overboard if the assumed use does not come up within a set time frame.
In other words I prefer ruthless goal orientation over a collector’s mindset.

#20

I don’t like that mentality.

[speculation redacted]

The Obsidian community is enormous and diverse, including academics, students, researchers, artists, journalists, professionals, hobbyists, writers, TTRPG players, language learners, and many more. Not everything everyone does here has a clear economic purpose. And sometimes raw knowledge must be mined and collected long before it is ever polished into something worthwhile.

1 Like
#21

No, I am not in marketing.
Goal setting and accomplishing is a very rewarding and satisfying activity in every single branch that exists and if you don’t focus on it, your approach will be inefficient or even, which is my point, ineffective.
You will gather for the sake of gathering.
Not my cup of tea.

#22

Why do you take notes and do you take notes for a specific topic?

#23

Without Obsidian I took notes as checklists. I used a texteditor which I have a key assigned to on my keyboard, so it is immediately there.
Then I remove each line that I accomplished.
Other times I collect all of my ideas for a topic and put them in a mindmap, order them and then I do something with them, like writing a structured letter or creating a product.
I can do none of that with obsidian as efficiently.
O. is a convoluted collection of text files. Clicking on one link makes me forget the context it was in. Then it’s like mindless browsing without a goal on the web, aka procrastination.
Why do you take notes and do you take notes for a specific topic?

#24

I also collect ideas for a topic and later on I do something with them. I use obsidian because of the many little handy features it offers.

#25

Why don’t you use mindmaps for that?

#26

In my case, I was looking for a markdown editor that supports LaTeX and was crossplatform for Android and Windows. Besides that I really like that the internal links are dynamic. If you change the name of a note, the links will be updated automatically. Not a lot markdown editors have this feature.

#27

Why do you use a (markdown) editor instead of a mindmap?
You say compatibility, so you don’t care whether it’s a good or even working solution, all that matters for you is that it works on both android and windows?

I get the impression that everyone is avoiding the question here, is that just me who has this impression?

#28

You seem to prefer mindmaps. Nothing wrong with mindmaps! They’re a great tool too.

¯\( ツ )/¯

#29

That is an assumption you are making.

#30

It is a question. Is it accurate?

#31

The original question was: Share how obsidian helped you. Yet you keep talking about ‘mentality’ and things you personally do not like. That’s not all that effective, is it now?

#32

That’s a pretty broad (and baseless) generalization. I’m sure you can find a community like that somewhere. Participation is optional…

#33